Life Is A Process

Life Is A Process

Life is a Process

The video showing the building of a protein molecule resembles a robotic assembly line in a factory.  These are examples of process control system designed to build a product.  The company I founded, Vehicle Monitor Corporation (VMC), designs and builds systems that orchestrate the work that takes place at vehicle assembly line stations.  This work is a process whereby at each workstation, value is added by completing one of the assembly line processes. A typical example is adding a part, testing to verify proper function with no damage, and  measuring and documenting the work done.

The factories that VMC serves are very similar to the protein synthesis illustrated in Steve Meyer’s video from a functionality point of view.  Transcribing the DNA to mRNA and the transport of this mRNA to the ribosome is analogous to the delivery of the custom-specific details to the factory workstation with the arrival of the vehicle.  The translation process that occurs in the ribosome is analogous to the value add that occurs at a factory workstation.  Both need the delivery of right piece parts Just-In-Time,1  Transporting the protein molecule from the ribosome to the chaperone is analogous to a vehicle being moved from one work station to the next.  The folding of the protein in the chaperone is analogous to the vehicle getting its adjustments and tune-up at the last workstation, both leaving out the back door.  

A process is defined as “a systematic series of actions directed to some end”.  Watching this video shows the ribosome in action leaving no doubt that the protein synthesis meets this definition.  As with the factory, the protein synthesis involves work performed at specified places.  The activity at each workstation involves many individual actions. such as, picking a specified piece, placing the piece at a specified location, and bonding it into place.  Each of these actions is purpose driven work, which if not executed properly, will result in failure.  Both examples need the parts to be delivered to each work station, and the product must be transported from one work station to the next.  Both involve specific instructions for each product that comes down the production line. 

Much detail was missing in the video that is obvious to an engineer who has had to make complex systems work.  The nucleotide and amino acid molecules just “fly into place”.  In reality, these molecules must be pre-assembled, staged, delivered at the correct time and position without the expenditure of excess energy that will damage the machines, polymer or surrounding molecules.

The fact that life is a process is not disputed.  My wife’s college circa 1960 biology textbook2 defines life as a”..a process, or rather a series of interacting processes which are always associated with, and take place in, a complex organization of materials.”   What is missing in this definition is the distinction between a natural process and an intelligent process.  This same book has no direct mention of molecular machines, making it obvious that much has been learned in the last 50 years.3

The world of biology at that time recognized that there are molecular machines4 working in the cell performing tasks such as building proteins by the ribosome machine.

“The ribosome is an “RNA machine” that “involves more than 300 proteins and RNAs” to form a complex where messenger RNA is translated into protein, thereby playing a crucial role in protein synthesis in the cell. Craig Venter, a leader in genomics and the Human Genome Project, has called the ribosome “an incredibly beautiful complex entity” which requires a “minimum for the ribosome about 53 proteins and 3 polynucleotides,” leading some evolutionist biologists to fear that it may be irreducibly complex.”5

In addition to processes that occur on an “as needed” basis, like replacing a protein that has fallen to equilibrium and is no longer functional, there are “life cycle” processes  that take place as shown in figure 2.  Processes are typically bottom-up, top-down with layered individual smaller processes that are steps or supporting actions required to accomplish the overall process.

It seems obvious that biology is not just about chemistry, it is also about machines working in life processes.  Life in every cell that has ever existed, in every life form that has ever lived on earth, and all of the interactions among life forms, is what this engineer thinks of as The Life Process. It is a hierarchy of processes over time, within cells and within life forms.

 

© 2016 Mike Van Schoiack

Paper: On The Limits Of Natural Causes

Paper: On The Limits Of Natural Causes

The concepts underlying the Intelligent Design section of this site are contained in this paper entitled “On the Limits of Natural Causes” in a published paper format.

Here is the abstract:

Abstract

 The debate surrounding the origins of first life focus on disproving the materialist doctrine that all that exists can be explained by matter, energy, space, time and the laws of physics and that there is a chemical pathway to first life. The Intelligent Design (ID) argument is that life is very complex, requiring high degrees of specified information, design, with vast coherence, making the probability of natural causes finding a viable life solution orders of magnitude longer than the age of the universe.

This paper posits another, more powerful ID argument based on three premises: 1) that outcomes of natural processes, defined as processes that follow the laws of physics with no intelligence involved, are limited due to logical constraints, 2) life is an intelligent process which requires machinery to function , and 3) machines require embedded intelligent functionality which is beyond the reach of natural causes.

The rationale behind these premises is explained in this paper, and a simple means of falsifying them posited. The necessity to consider not only the design of life but the actual building, starting and operation of life is invoked by the arguments presented here. The research for this paper lead to findings that have significance:

  1. They show that there is intelligence embedded in life meaning that life itself is not just science, it is science plus logic (intelligence) which is in the realm of philosophy,
  2. They move the ID argument natural causes created life from being insanely improbable to impossible,
  3. They provide the basis for definitive, coherent definitions of life, science, engineering and philosophy,
  4. They provide methods to falsify the idea that there is a chemical pathway to first life, and that natural causes can create machines.

 

Link to this paper.

© 2018 Mike Van Schoiack

 

 

 

© 2016 Mike Van Schoiack

Designed by Mike Van Schoiack, Powered by WordPress/Divi

Biology’s Path to the Future

Biology’s Path to the Future

Biology Today – Headed Down the Wrong Path?

It would have been logical to assume chemistry governed biology before the realization that molecular machines built proteins, DNA, RNA and physical structures within the cell. But enzymes are still called catalysts, and catalysts are called chemicals that speed up a chemical reaction.

Chemical reactions are a different paradigm compared to molecular machines.  Machines require embedded intelligence and continual energy consumption while running.  Chemical reactions can occur without intelligence and its energy requirement. Could the materialist ideology that permeates the field of biology be the reason it views life through a chemical lens sans engineering?

Biologists have made great progress nevertheless.  The ability to observe and measure what is actually happening in the cell was (and still is) very limited due to the microscopic size, 3-D, non-homogeneous envirnoment. Non-biological chemists do chemistry in bulk quantities which has limited use in biology due to its dependency upon highly specified complex, dynamic arrangements of matter/energy.  These qualities makes reverse engineering life next to impossible.

The failure of biology to accept life being engineered results in wasted resources, time, energy and lives.

Life Needs to be Reverse Engineered

It is this engineer’s opinion that reverse engineering life is possibly the most significant advancement that mankind should now be pursuing.  The benefits of having a detailed understanding of life are obvious, especially in the field of medicine.  We could be better stewards of the world.  It will help us adapt to changing conditions and to space travel.  This may be the reason we exist!

Here are some thoughts about how this project might be organized.

Give the Project a Name

This project would be mankind’s biggest undertaking to date, far bigger than the human genome and ENCODE projects, and even bigger and more challenging than putting a man on the moon, Hubble and the Hadron Collider.  An exaggeration? Life is far more complex than anything mankind has encountered, and we do not have means to directly observe the life process in detail.  A project of this importance deserves a great name.

Define Goals

Defining the goals is the obvious start of any project.  Here are a few straw-man ideas.

Explicitly Define the Knowledge to be Pursued, and the Form it is Documented

The main, high-level goal is to have complete, “know all there is to know” knowledge of life.  This should also include understanding the functionality in terms of what each entity is doing, how it is doing it, why it is doing it, and how the process actions relate to each other. There needs to be a top-down (coherency of all functionalities) as well as a bottom-up understanding.

The proposal here is to think of life as a process with thousands of process tasks, to identify each of these tasks, diagram how these tasks relate to each other (linkage notation system) and identify the inputs, signaling means, the logic processing means, and the actuator means of each task. 

And there should be a method of cataloging and referencing supporting information such as books, papers, studies, videos, educational materials, medical links, etc.6

A possibility would be a cross between a Wikipedia format with a biology Dewey Decimal system.

Form a Standards Committee Consisting of Qualified Engineers and Biologists

The first task would be to assemble highly qualified people to design the process to be followed and organize the effort.  Thousands of contributors will very quickly become involved once standards have been established.  This group could morph into the role of on-going maintenance and management.

Develop Research Tools and Methods

The development of methods and tools for doing research would be a needed parallel effort.  Because of the theoretical limitations of observing molecules, computer simulation can become a method of analyzing molecular machine function.  For example, it seems that the natural folding of a protein has been successfully modeled, and it seems that this method could be expanded to simulate molecular machine operation.  Again, forming a group to study and promote such efforts, and to provide a database for best practices, tools and methods would be worthwhile.

© 2018 Mike Van Schoiack

 

Mechanism

Mechanism

Cambridge Dictionary Definition

  1. a part of a machine, or a set of parts that work together.
  2. a.  a way of doing something, esp. one that is planned or part of a systsem.

Brick’s Law Definition

  1. Components, elements, or parts, and the associated energy and information flows enabling a machine, process, or system to achieve its intended result within this type of logical assembly.

Author’s Definition

  1. a part of a machine, or a set of parts that work together.
  2. a methodology including componenents, elements, parts and the associated energy and information flows enabling a machine, process or system that has demonstrated the ability to achieve its intended result.

Note: This definition is tweaked to include only proven methodologies.

© 2016 Mike Van Schoiack

Engineer

Engineer

Oxford Dictionaries Definition

Noun 1. a person who designs and builds machines and objects for a specified purpose.

Verb  1. Design and build a machine or structure.

Author’s Definition

Noun 1. a person who designs and builds machines and objects for a specified purpose.

Verb  1. Design and build a machine or object for a specified purpose.

Noun 2. a person who performs intelligent work to create entities that natural causes either cannot or cannot in the quantity, time or speed desired.

  Note: This definition in included to distinguish design vs. actualization as it seems they are often conflated, and to exclude maintenance with is typically the role of a technician.

© 2016 Mike Van Schoiack